Do It Right Plumbing
$99 first-time drain cleaning, free camera scope included →Text photos to 602-596-3013 for a free rough estimate →

Plumbing Advice

What Size Water Heater Do I Need for My Family in Phoenix?

By Kenneth Parks ·

What Size Water Heater Do I Need for My Family? | Phoenix

The short answer

The right water heater size for a Phoenix family is not really about gallons. It is about how much hot water you use in your busiest hour, a number manufacturers print on every tank as the first-hour rating. As a starting point, one or two people usually do fine with a 40-gallon tank, three or four with a 50-gallon, and five or more with a fast-recovering 50-gallon gas unit or a 65- to 80-gallon electric. Tankless units are sized by flow instead. Here is how I work through it on a water heater installation so a family does not buy too small or too big.

Start with your busiest hour, not your head count

Two families of four can need very different heaters. One spreads showers across the day. The other has three teenagers who shower back to back at 6 a.m. while the dishwasher runs. The second family needs more hot water in one hour, and that is what the first-hour rating measures: how many gallons the tank can deliver in an hour starting full, counting what it reheats along the way.

Add up your peak hour. A shower runs roughly 10 to 15 gallons of hot water, a bath 15 to 20, a dishwasher cycle about 6, and a warm laundry load 7 or so. Total your worst hour, then look for a tank whose first-hour rating meets or beats it. If your family hits 70 gallons at 6 a.m., a tank with a 50-gallon first-hour rating will disappoint you no matter how new it is.

Gas and electric do not size the same

A gas burner reheats water faster than electric elements, so a 40-gallon gas tank often has a first-hour rating close to a 50-gallon electric. That is why gas households can usually go one size smaller than electric with the same demand. I covered the fuel trade-offs in gas vs. electric water heater for a Phoenix home. For sizing, remember that recovery speed is part of capacity.

Sizing a tankless is a different math

A tankless water heater has no first-hour rating because it has no tank. It is rated by how many gallons per minute it can heat across a given temperature rise. Count the fixtures you want running at once; two showers and a kitchen faucet might pull 5 or 6 gallons per minute. Phoenix helps here: incoming water is around 80 degrees in summer and in the 50s or 60s in winter, warmer than up north. Even so, a January morning with 55-degree water and a 120-degree setpoint is a 65-degree rise, and the unit has to hold your flow at that rise. Size for winter. Undersized tankless units are the ones people call cold showers.

A Peoria family that bought big and still ran out

A family in Peoria called me after replacing their 40-gallon electric with a 50-gallon electric and still losing hot water on school mornings. The tank was fine. Three showers and a load of laundry happened inside twenty minutes, and a slow-recovering electric could not keep up no matter what the label said. We worked out their peak hour, talked through a gas conversion since they had a line nearby, and installed a 50-gallon gas unit with a much higher first-hour rating. Same closet, and the mornings stopped being a fight. They had sized by gallons when they should have sized by their busiest hour.

The honest counterpoint: bigger is not always better

Oversizing has a cost too. A tank that holds far more than you use keeps that water hot around the clock, and a tankless unit sized for the guests you host twice a year is more equipment than you need. Empty-nesters replacing the 80-gallon tank from the kid years can often go smaller. And if your hot water runs out suddenly after years of being fine, the tank size has not changed, so something inside it has. I covered those causes in why does my hot water run out so fast. Sizing is for a new installation. Running out on a heater that used to work is a repair call.

Not sure what water heater size you need? Text me a photo

Do It Right Plumbing has been family owned and operated in west Phoenix since 2006, and I have been sizing and installing water heaters for more than 35 years. Text a photo of your current heater and how many people live in the house to 602-596-3013 for a free rough estimate, or call 602-428-2585 to talk through the right water heater size with a licensed plumber (ROC #219450). Every installation carries our one-year parts and labor warranty plus a six-year manufacturer warranty on the heater, and you will know the price before we start. Do It Right Plumbing is here when you are ready.

Not sure what water heater size you need? Text me a photo

See the details

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a 40-gallon water heater enough for a family of four?

Usually not for electric, and only sometimes for gas. A family of four with staggered showers can get by on a 40-gallon gas unit with a strong first-hour rating. If showers cluster in one hour or you have a soaking tub, a 50-gallon tank is the safer choice.

What size tankless water heater do I need in Phoenix?

Size by flow at a winter temperature rise. Count the fixtures you run at once, estimate their combined gallons per minute, and choose a unit that delivers that flow at roughly a 60- to 65-degree rise. Size for January, not July.

Does a bigger water heater raise my utility bill?

A larger tank holds more hot water on standby, so there is some added energy use, and a larger gas unit may need a bigger gas line or vent. The difference is modest on a modern insulated tank. The bigger waste is buying a unit sized for a household you no longer have.

Need a Plumber Today?

Call 602-428-2585 and talk to a real person, or send us the details and we'll call you back.

Call NowText Photos