Do It Right Plumbing
$99 first-time drain cleaning, free camera scope included →Text photos to 602-596-3013 for a free rough estimate →

Plumbing Advice

Gas vs Electric Water Heater: Best for Phoenix Homes?

By Kenneth Parks ·

Gas vs Electric Water Heater: Best for Phoenix Homes?

In the gas vs electric water heater question, the honest answer for most Phoenix homes is to stay with whatever fuel you already have, because the lines, venting and wiring are already there. If you are starting fresh, gas recovers hot water faster and costs less to run in most Valley homes, while electric is simpler to install, needs no venting, and makes sense where there is no gas service. Here is how I think through it.

How the two heat water differently

A gas water heater has a burner under the tank and a flue up the middle, and it heats a 50 gallon tank quickly enough to keep up with back-to-back showers. An electric tank has two heating elements inside the water. They are quiet and need no gas line or vent, but they recover more slowly, so a big family on electric may run out before the same family on gas. If your hot water runs out fast on a gas unit, that is usually a sizing or sediment problem, not the fuel, and we covered that in an earlier post. Here we are only comparing the fuels.

What the Phoenix garage does to the decision

Most Valley water heaters live in the garage. Gas heaters there sit on a stand so the burner is 18 inches off the floor, and they need combustion air and a vent through the roof. Electric heaters need neither, which is why many homes built without gas service went electric. Our garages also run hot, which helps both types since the incoming water is already warm half the year. On the other hand, a monsoon power outage takes an electric heater out completely, while a standard gas tank with a pilot keeps working.

Operating cost, in relative terms

I will not quote a number, because rates change, but in the Phoenix area a gas tank usually costs less to run month to month than a standard electric tank. The newer heat pump electric water heaters flip that. They pull heat out of the garage air, which we have plenty of, and can run cheaper than gas in our climate. They cost more up front, need room to breathe, and recover slowly, so they fit a small household with a roomy garage and not a big family. If you want electric with lower bills, that is the version to ask about.

A Peoria family that switched to gas

A family in Peoria called me because their electric tank could not get three teenagers through the morning. The house had gas at the range but never at the water heater. We ran a new gas line across the garage, pulled the permit, installed a 50 gallon gas tank on a stand with a new vent, and pressure-tested the line before we left. The teenagers stopped fighting over the first shower. The gas line was extra work, but it was a one-time job, and they got a faster heater that costs less to run for the next decade.

When I tell people to stay electric

Here is the counterpoint. If your home has no gas service, bringing it in from the street is a big project, and electric is the right call. If the heater is in an interior closet with no good way to vent, electric avoids a flue entirely. If your household is one or two people, an electric tank or heat pump unit keeps up fine. And if you have solar panels, daytime electric heating uses energy you already paid for. I have talked plenty of people out of switching to gas, because the switch only pays off when the house and the family fit it.

Hard water does not care which fuel you pick

Phoenix water is very hard, and sediment builds up in both types. In a gas tank it settles on the bottom and makes the burner work through a layer of rock, which is the popping sound people hear. In an electric tank it buries the lower element and burns it out. An annual flush and an eye on the anode rod matter more than the fuel. Any water heater repair visit from us includes a look at both.

Need help choosing a gas vs electric water heater?

Do It Right Plumbing has been family owned and operated since 2006, and I have more than 35 years in the trade. We are licensed, bonded and insured, AZ ROC #219450, with a 1-year parts and labor warranty on every job and a 6-year manufacturer warranty on the water heaters we install. Text a photo of your current heater to 602-596-3013 for a free rough estimate, or call 602-428-2585 and we will talk through water heater installation for your house.

Gas vs electric water heater is less about which fuel wins and more about which fits your house. Match the fuel to your gas service, your venting and your family size, and either one will serve you well.

Whichever fuel you choose, a tank-style heater on a closed plumbing system needs an expansion tank, and a dripping relief valve is the usual sign one is missing. Read do I need a water heater expansion tank in Phoenix.

Fuel choice also changes the size you need, because a gas burner recovers faster than electric elements and a 40-gallon gas tank can match a 50-gallon electric in real-world hot water. Once you have picked a fuel, use what size water heater do I need for my family in Phoenix to pick the capacity.

Need help choosing a gas vs electric water heater?

See the details

Frequently asked questions

Can I switch from electric to gas water heater?

Yes, if the house has gas service. It means a new gas line, a vent, a permit and usually a stand in the garage. It is a one-time job that makes sense for larger households.

Which lasts longer, gas or electric?

They are close. Electric tanks have fewer parts and sometimes edge out gas by a year or two, but Phoenix hard water is the bigger factor for both. Flushing matters more than the fuel.

Is a heat pump water heater worth it in Phoenix?

For a small household with a warm garage and room around the unit, often yes. For a big family that needs fast recovery, usually no.

Need a Plumber Today?

Call 602-428-2585 and talk to a real person, or send us the details and we'll call you back.

Call NowText Photos